The Quest: Best & Worst Pilots Ever


Pilots and Petards Podcast is on a quest. We are determined to find the best and worst pilots ever. We will keep a running list of pilots as we review and analyze them each week.

Below is the running list of pilots from best to worst:

  1. End of the Fing World
  2. This Is Us
  3. Breaking Bad
  4. One Punch Man
  5. True Detective “The Long Bright Dark”
  6. Black-ish
  7. Better Call Saul “Uno”
  8. Dexter “Dexter”
  9. Pose “Pilot”
  10. The Handmaid’s Tale “Offred”
  11. The Shield
  12. Killing Eve
  13. The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel “Pilot”
  14. My Name Is Earl
  15. X-Men the Animated Series
  16. Game of Thrones “Winter Is Coming”
  17. The Wonder Years
  18. This Close
  19. Russian Doll “Nothing in This World Is Easy”
  20. Barry “Chapter One: Make Your Mark”
  21. Rick and Morty
  22. It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia
  23. The Good Place “Everything Is Fine”
  24. Umbrella Academy “We Only See Each Other at Weddings and Funerals”
  25. Big Little Lies “Somebody’s Dead”
  26. You “Pilot”
  27. Young Justice “Independence Day”
  28. A Million Little Things “Pilot”
  29. The Punisher
  30. Friday Night Lights
  31. Bodyguard “Episode 1”
  32. Westworld “The Original”
  33. South Park
  34. The Crown
  35. Cheers
  36. Sex Education “Episode 1”
  37. Alias Grace
  38. The Haunting of Hill House “Steven Sees a Ghost”
  39. Tom Clancy’s Jack Ryan “Pilot”
  40. Castle Rock “Severance”
  41. Manifest “Pilot”
  42. Cobra Kai
  43. Lost
  44. Sopranos
  45. Boy Meets World
  46. Married with Children
  47. I Feel Bad “Pilot”
  48. Law and Order SVU
  49. Freaks and Geeks
  50. Dawson’s Creek
  51. Altered Carbon “Out of the Past”
  52. Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt “Kimmy Goes Outside”
  53. Deadly Class “Pilot”
  54. Cloak and Dagger “First Light”
  55. Glee
  56. Supernatural
  57. Justified “Fire in the Hole”
  58. Single Parents
  59. Doom Patrol “Pilot”
  60. Firefly
  61. One Tree Hill
  62. Wonderfalls
  63. The Cool Kids “Pilot”
  64. Rel “Pilot”
  65. Batman Beyond
  66. New Amsterdam “Pilot”
  67. Ally McBeal
  68. DC Titans “Titans”
  69. The Rookie “Pilot”
  70. Six Feet Under “Pilot”
  71. PEN15 “First Day”
  72. Alex Inc
  73. Dream On “The First Episode”
  74. Sons of Anarchy “Pilot”
  75. Spawn “Burning Vision”
  76. 7th Heaven
  77. Buffy the Vampire Slayer

7 thoughts on “The Quest: Best & Worst Pilots Ever

Add yours

  1. I agree!

    Unfortunately Mo has a raging NB for Glee. So Supernatural will unlikely advance, but for future rankings it would help to swing that split decision.


  2. End of the Fucking world is a mini-series adaptation of a novel, and it’s so short and focused it’s really just a movie cut up. There was no pilot, a pilot is a testing grounds, so I don’t really think it belongs here.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Hmm, Jzakko that is a fair point. None of our other pilots fit that description. It did air as the first episode of a series and it ended with room for another season. I’ll discuss it with the gang.

    I think that could be said about a lot of shows. Does it matter that they stretch a story out? Friday Night Lights was a movie retold as a series, same with Buffy.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: